Press "Enter" to skip to content

Kerala couple wins legal battle against Pune resort after their two sons drown

Representational Image

Three years have passed, but P V Prakashan and his wife Vanaja Prakashan of Amballur, Ernakulam in Kerala are yet to come out of the shock of losing their two sons in a drowning incident at a resort in Pune. Recognising the alleged negligence on the part of the resort in ensuring the safety of their sons – Midhun Prakash P, 30, and Nidhin Prakash P, 24, who drowned in a pond at the resort, the couple fought for justice and has finally won a verdict from the Ernakulam Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, which ordered the resort to pay compensation of Rs 1.99 crore to the couple.

“We were shattered when we heard about the incident. We decided to legally fight against the resort when we had to face harassment at the hands of the resort authorities,” said Prakashan. Though no compensation would fill the vacuum created in their life, the couple decided to fight the case as a social commitment to ensure that these kinds of incidents do not recur, and there are adequate safety measures at these spots marketed to attract youth.

It was on October 24, 2020 that Midhun and Nidhin, along with 22 others, booked rooms at the resort identified as Karandi Valley Adventure and Agro Tourism Resort in Pune. The next day, both Midhun and Nidhin drowned in a pond at the resort. The couple initiated legal proceedings against the resort citing gross negligence in ensuring the safety of its patrons. Arguing that the resort had failed to adhere to basic safety protocols and maintain vigilant lifeguard services, the couple contended that the tragedy could have been averted had the resort taken adequate measures to prevent such accidents.

The Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, chaired by President D B Binu, member V Ramachandran, and Sreevidhia T N, after carefully examining the evidence and testimonies, allowed the prayer of the couple, acknowledging the lapses in the resort’s safety measures. In its order, the commission directed Karandi Valley Adventure and Agro Tourism Resort to pay compensation of Rs 1.99 crore to the couple. The court’s decision has set a precedent, sending a strong message to adventure resorts about the importance of prioritising guest safety.


  1. Any backar Barkatullah Baramulla naseeruddin December 18, 2023

    This is very essential…

    As such resorts are mushrooming around big cities by the investment from many business stalwarts… Whose main aim is profit profit 😝😜 exorbitant profit, and fail to build the respective standards of safety.
    Hope this verdict will set precedents, and wake them up to visit and see the safety in their investments

  2. Anonymous December 18, 2023

    Safely is neither consern or priority , No norms ..

  3. Balasubramanian R December 18, 2023

    There are government agencies to undertake periodic inspections of these Resorts, which they fail to do but issue compliance certificate against favour. Further many Resorts have no licence to operate but still operate by the strength of local political backup. Even in most jungle resorts, the safety aspects is very minimal as they are not aware of the animal which stroll at night as most are nocturnal.
    People should be doubly careful while venturing in to Resorts for holiday spending.
    If management have respect and value for their customers such incidents will never occur.
    Balasubramanian Bangalore

  4. VISWANATHAN Iyer December 18, 2023

    It’s high time both central and state governments become proactive and regulate all resorts mushrooming all over the land just as hotels and prescribe safety standards around all resorts. Resorts are getaways for youngsters, families with children as also elders.

  5. Anonymous December 18, 2023

    Good verdict. This should be a lesson for such places to know the value of a life. 🙏

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

10 Minimalist Habits for a Stress-Free Life Kerala’s Enchanting Beaches for Destination Weddings Kerala’s Captivating Hill Stations for Your Summer Escapades Conquering Cerebral Palsy: Dr. Nanda’s Journey of Perseverance and Compassion This Kerala youth with rare genetic condition fought body shaming to succeed in life 4.5 acres of barren land into farm: 3 friends’ organic farming venture in Kerala Do not discard used cooking oil: Learn about Kerala RUCO Project At 61, this retired Kerala professor is dancing her way to her dream Muslim percussionist’s Sopana Sangeetham at Kerala temple How 7 Friends in Kerala Built a Dam, Powered a Hospital